How Do I Love Thee?
For some reason the following things have been huddling together in a corner of my mind, so I’ll go with them…
PARENTS WORRY. It is what we do. We worry for our children, over our children, because of our children and on behalf of our children. Love—human love, at least—causes it; a worry of hopes and fears born of our love. I know all about where this conversation could go, about the Love of God and that perfect love drives out fear, and the ways religion has come to interpret these ideas. And I know religion tries to teach us that worry is a lack of faith. I know that some people say it is a sin. I know all that. But it doesn’t change the fact that we worry. I think that to deny the worry and pretend it doesn’t exist is a lie. We worry. It is what we do. In big ways and tiny ways, we worry.
One of the worries is that you aren’t a good parent. It’s a worry reserved for people who at least want to be good parents, whether they succeed or not. I worry this worry. Will my children learn the right things from me? Will they learn the one or two things I want with all of my heart for them to learn? Will they succeed in not learning the many things I don’t want them to learn? In the end, will I have done okay?
My mom and dad think about this. I can tell. Only for them of course the worry has passed through the years into wonder—wonder about the present status of what was once worried about. My mom mentions it explicitly every once in a while. My dad has mentioned it once that I recall. “I was wondering how you remember me,” he said, “do you remember me as a dad who was there?”
“I guess I remember you as daddy” is the answer I gave, as best as I recall. He deserved a better answer, as does my mom whenever she asks. And I tend to think that everyone who loves me deserves better answers than I give. The quick and simple answers they would like from me do not come easily. I know this makes me hard to love, and it makes it hard to know how—and if—I love in return. I know this. But what am I to say?
AS A TEENAGER I stood in front of a window and looked south to the small pasture of the house where I lived at the time. One of our little goats had gone down, and my dad was out there on his hands and knees, working to resuscitate it. He tried for a while and then he finally stood up, picked up the little lifeless body in front of him, and carried it away. He was wiping his eyes periodically as he walked back toward the house. Dads don’t cry often. At all. Almost never. But I stood there and watched my dad cry, alone in his element. Over a little goat. A simple and gentle little life gone. He had spent most of his life caring for animals, and his career controlling disease in communities of man, but he could not save this one little creature.
I was young, in elementary school, and dad was away on business one Christmas. For reasons no longer important, my mother was too shy in her own way to go outside of the house and drive to a Christmas tree lot to find us a tree. So she went out to our garage and fashioned some sticks into a big triangle, and leaned them against our living room wall. Then with little lights and aluminum foil, she decorated it. I still remember saying, in the myopic mindset of childhood, that her lovingly crafted tree looked stupid. I have come to regret that comment all these years later. It is that tree from my childhood that shines in my memory above others. It was a beautiful tree that spoke of love and devotion and creativity working in the face of limitations imposed upon a person from within and without. It was a symbol of how what is good and loving within us overcomes the lesser things—of how love always finds a way.
And now in two thousand six I have my own family, and our dog is getting old. She can no longer hear and her eyes are getting cloudy. The cold weather stoves up her hips, leaving her to hobble about in the mornings. What I find most beautiful about her these days is a simple thing. Although she cannot hear me, she watches me intently during our morning and evening rituals. A gesture of my hand tells her to come or to go and what path to take. She will stand staring at me until I curl and twitch my fingers, and with sweeping wags of her giant tail she will scurry as best as she can to comply with my direction. I suppose a person would have to see her, to watch her and perhaps to love her to see the beauty of it, but it is a gorgeous thing. It speaks to me of life’s desire to go on living and to find and take what is still good in any circumstance. It is the strength of life that is seen in her weakness. It is a beautiful thing—truly beautiful.
I have known a lot of dogs, and so I know what it means to say that our old dog is a good dog. Some days I could swear she has a soul. And on those days I hope that, wherever our spirits go when we die, hers goes there too. She is so kind and so gentle and so loving that I think she deserves a place like that—a place where she is no longer deaf and her eyes are no longer cloudy and her hips don’t ache in the cold. A place where she can run all day like she is young again. A place where she can sleep warmly all night curled up next to her Master. She deserves a place like that. She truly does.
It is likely that some time all too soon, on a day not far off, I will spend my final day with this kind old dog and the last thing I will ever do for her in her life is to hold her in my arms while her life is ended in what I hope with all my heart is painlessness. But I already know in this realization that she is deaf, and she won’t be able to hear my voice as I hold her close to my chest and rest my face upon hers. She won’t be able to hear the voice that has comforted her and kept her calm and courageous through the years, through all sorts of aches and pains and accidents and injuries. She won’t be able to hear me at all, to have my voice warm and safe and known to trust and hold to in her last breathing minute. My heart will break in that moment, and it will ache on that day, ache for a strong and happy dog of titanic spirit who has finally run out of strength, and whose spirit has finally departed. In that moment a part of me will die a little, for I will not be able to be for her all the things I want to be, nor the one thing I most need to be. And by this I am shadowed even today by the coming sadness.
IT IS the nature of life that in the end we cannot always save the things we love the most. This is what makes the loving all the more valuable—and all the more costly. In the final analysis of life, it is love that hurts the most, and this is life’s greatest and final irony—that the most beautiful thing of all, is also the most painful thing of all.
If it is true that God gave humanity free will in order that God’s love may be chosen, and therefore that it may reach its fullness somewhere tomorrow in eternity, then think of this some night when you are alone. Think of all the horror, so much of it unspeakable, that mankind’s free will has brought to Man. Think of the nightmares of evil we can scarcely bare, and that yet they were somehow long ago worth a cosmic trade in the heart and mind of God. Think that somehow, somewhere, some when, the glory of God’s Love will be worth the agony of every evil. I have thought such a thing in my tears of mourning for all the pain in the world. And when I have done so, I have shivered in the warmth of the day, so enthralled as to be almost frightened by a Love so great. This Love is the God in Whom I hope and trust. This Love is the God to Whom every one of my life’s tears belong.
And this is how I love, for those of you who want to know. I love in the hopes that were never fulfilled. I love in the worries that came to naught and in those which came to fruition. I love in what was hoped for yet never arrived. I love in the longings we have to rescue and save what we ultimately cannot. I love in the triumph of life that makes us succeed in spite of ourselves. I love in life’s insatiable desire to go on living. I love in the face of a triumph beyond words that is made known in all of our frailty, in all of our failure, and in all of our sorrow. I love what the world sees as ugly, because it is made beautiful in God.
HOW DO I love thee? I’m not sure I have ever known. I’m no longer sure I can answer, no matter how far away I go nor how deeply I try to gaze inside myself. I simply love what Is, and I love you as the part of It you are. What I do not know is if this is enough. But to me, it is everything there is.
And for my children, will this be enough? For my children, for whom my love knows no bounds, will they come to know what I know, to see what I see? I do not know. I cannot know. And so I worry. We are parents. It is what we do.
PARENTS WORRY. It is what we do. We worry for our children, over our children, because of our children and on behalf of our children. Love—human love, at least—causes it; a worry of hopes and fears born of our love. I know all about where this conversation could go, about the Love of God and that perfect love drives out fear, and the ways religion has come to interpret these ideas. And I know religion tries to teach us that worry is a lack of faith. I know that some people say it is a sin. I know all that. But it doesn’t change the fact that we worry. I think that to deny the worry and pretend it doesn’t exist is a lie. We worry. It is what we do. In big ways and tiny ways, we worry.
One of the worries is that you aren’t a good parent. It’s a worry reserved for people who at least want to be good parents, whether they succeed or not. I worry this worry. Will my children learn the right things from me? Will they learn the one or two things I want with all of my heart for them to learn? Will they succeed in not learning the many things I don’t want them to learn? In the end, will I have done okay?
My mom and dad think about this. I can tell. Only for them of course the worry has passed through the years into wonder—wonder about the present status of what was once worried about. My mom mentions it explicitly every once in a while. My dad has mentioned it once that I recall. “I was wondering how you remember me,” he said, “do you remember me as a dad who was there?”
“I guess I remember you as daddy” is the answer I gave, as best as I recall. He deserved a better answer, as does my mom whenever she asks. And I tend to think that everyone who loves me deserves better answers than I give. The quick and simple answers they would like from me do not come easily. I know this makes me hard to love, and it makes it hard to know how—and if—I love in return. I know this. But what am I to say?
AS A TEENAGER I stood in front of a window and looked south to the small pasture of the house where I lived at the time. One of our little goats had gone down, and my dad was out there on his hands and knees, working to resuscitate it. He tried for a while and then he finally stood up, picked up the little lifeless body in front of him, and carried it away. He was wiping his eyes periodically as he walked back toward the house. Dads don’t cry often. At all. Almost never. But I stood there and watched my dad cry, alone in his element. Over a little goat. A simple and gentle little life gone. He had spent most of his life caring for animals, and his career controlling disease in communities of man, but he could not save this one little creature.
I was young, in elementary school, and dad was away on business one Christmas. For reasons no longer important, my mother was too shy in her own way to go outside of the house and drive to a Christmas tree lot to find us a tree. So she went out to our garage and fashioned some sticks into a big triangle, and leaned them against our living room wall. Then with little lights and aluminum foil, she decorated it. I still remember saying, in the myopic mindset of childhood, that her lovingly crafted tree looked stupid. I have come to regret that comment all these years later. It is that tree from my childhood that shines in my memory above others. It was a beautiful tree that spoke of love and devotion and creativity working in the face of limitations imposed upon a person from within and without. It was a symbol of how what is good and loving within us overcomes the lesser things—of how love always finds a way.
And now in two thousand six I have my own family, and our dog is getting old. She can no longer hear and her eyes are getting cloudy. The cold weather stoves up her hips, leaving her to hobble about in the mornings. What I find most beautiful about her these days is a simple thing. Although she cannot hear me, she watches me intently during our morning and evening rituals. A gesture of my hand tells her to come or to go and what path to take. She will stand staring at me until I curl and twitch my fingers, and with sweeping wags of her giant tail she will scurry as best as she can to comply with my direction. I suppose a person would have to see her, to watch her and perhaps to love her to see the beauty of it, but it is a gorgeous thing. It speaks to me of life’s desire to go on living and to find and take what is still good in any circumstance. It is the strength of life that is seen in her weakness. It is a beautiful thing—truly beautiful.
I have known a lot of dogs, and so I know what it means to say that our old dog is a good dog. Some days I could swear she has a soul. And on those days I hope that, wherever our spirits go when we die, hers goes there too. She is so kind and so gentle and so loving that I think she deserves a place like that—a place where she is no longer deaf and her eyes are no longer cloudy and her hips don’t ache in the cold. A place where she can run all day like she is young again. A place where she can sleep warmly all night curled up next to her Master. She deserves a place like that. She truly does.
It is likely that some time all too soon, on a day not far off, I will spend my final day with this kind old dog and the last thing I will ever do for her in her life is to hold her in my arms while her life is ended in what I hope with all my heart is painlessness. But I already know in this realization that she is deaf, and she won’t be able to hear my voice as I hold her close to my chest and rest my face upon hers. She won’t be able to hear the voice that has comforted her and kept her calm and courageous through the years, through all sorts of aches and pains and accidents and injuries. She won’t be able to hear me at all, to have my voice warm and safe and known to trust and hold to in her last breathing minute. My heart will break in that moment, and it will ache on that day, ache for a strong and happy dog of titanic spirit who has finally run out of strength, and whose spirit has finally departed. In that moment a part of me will die a little, for I will not be able to be for her all the things I want to be, nor the one thing I most need to be. And by this I am shadowed even today by the coming sadness.
IT IS the nature of life that in the end we cannot always save the things we love the most. This is what makes the loving all the more valuable—and all the more costly. In the final analysis of life, it is love that hurts the most, and this is life’s greatest and final irony—that the most beautiful thing of all, is also the most painful thing of all.
If it is true that God gave humanity free will in order that God’s love may be chosen, and therefore that it may reach its fullness somewhere tomorrow in eternity, then think of this some night when you are alone. Think of all the horror, so much of it unspeakable, that mankind’s free will has brought to Man. Think of the nightmares of evil we can scarcely bare, and that yet they were somehow long ago worth a cosmic trade in the heart and mind of God. Think that somehow, somewhere, some when, the glory of God’s Love will be worth the agony of every evil. I have thought such a thing in my tears of mourning for all the pain in the world. And when I have done so, I have shivered in the warmth of the day, so enthralled as to be almost frightened by a Love so great. This Love is the God in Whom I hope and trust. This Love is the God to Whom every one of my life’s tears belong.
And this is how I love, for those of you who want to know. I love in the hopes that were never fulfilled. I love in the worries that came to naught and in those which came to fruition. I love in what was hoped for yet never arrived. I love in the longings we have to rescue and save what we ultimately cannot. I love in the triumph of life that makes us succeed in spite of ourselves. I love in life’s insatiable desire to go on living. I love in the face of a triumph beyond words that is made known in all of our frailty, in all of our failure, and in all of our sorrow. I love what the world sees as ugly, because it is made beautiful in God.
HOW DO I love thee? I’m not sure I have ever known. I’m no longer sure I can answer, no matter how far away I go nor how deeply I try to gaze inside myself. I simply love what Is, and I love you as the part of It you are. What I do not know is if this is enough. But to me, it is everything there is.
And for my children, will this be enough? For my children, for whom my love knows no bounds, will they come to know what I know, to see what I see? I do not know. I cannot know. And so I worry. We are parents. It is what we do.

























